Effects of After-School Detention

Used as a form of punishment, what exactly are the pros and cons of detention and what is the effect it has on students? Read the article below.

Detention acts as a form of punishment in which teachers essentially keep students after school for an hour or two where they have to sit in a classroom in silence whilst doing any sort of work. Teachers use this to punish bad behavior in students and there are different types of detention like small lunch detention, or detention for the whole lunch period and the third is a long one hour after school detention which is given to students according to the severity of their misbehavior. They can also be given to students who break the rules set by the school system. These rules can be rules for clothing or the way these students conduct themselves or even the way they work.

Pros of Detention

Detention acts as a way to continue education after school, so essentially it is a frame of time in which the environment is controlled which is a huge benefit because students can sit in detention and do their homework instead of wasting time elsewhere or engaging in activities that could have an effect in harming their physical or mental health. Detention also helps students realize that they do not want to be in detention and so they decide to be better people by not getting themselves in detention in the first place. The added incentive of avoiding detention is the fact that no child wants to miss out on the lunch hour or time they could be spending their friends. Young children especially learn not to repeat bad behavior and this makes them sensible in the future. This way, they distract all other students less during lessons and like a chain reaction; it makes for more time that is spent on learning instead of doing anything else. It is getting harder to make children be respectful and so the threat of missing time for their lunch or time that could be spent with their friends so they refrain from acting out and being disrespectful. Simply put, what will the teachers do when the child hurts someone or even endangers themselves, because they cannot just write a report and send it to the parents of the child and furthermore, a sort of fear is created in the child which is the fear of getting into trouble, so they focus more on their studies which will help make them serious students.


Cons of Detention

Students miss out on jobs and other commitments due to these detentions as a lot of students have part-time jobs, and if for some reason a student ends up in detention, they can miss their shift which will cause them to lose their job. Another drawback is the fact that if a student gets detention it is a severe blow to their self-esteem because they might believe they that aren’t good enough students which is why they are in trouble and the student who gets sent to detention is degraded in front of his peers because they feel that they are in some way superior to the student in detention. This might lead to feelings of isolation and depression as the student might get bullied owing to the feelings of superiority. The bullying culture is already rampant without more fuel being added to the fire. Punishments also tend to increase bad behavior rather than decreasing it and anti-social behavior is also encouraged. Even by making extra time in school a form of punishment, it sends the message that more school is bad, rather than good. Thus, detention is perceived negatively rather than positively, and students avoid school rather than liking it or respecting it. Moreover, students generally use this time to sleep rather than work on their assignments so it just a waste as they do not learn anything, but rather they are forced to stay in an environment they dislike which to them, has no purpose. Detention only makes the children believe that when they do something wrong, they are separated from their friends for a specific period of time to think about what they did wrong. Punishment should be more constructive, such as getting the student to help out around the community or help the high school with projects that spark an interest in community service. This will teach them about the importance of giving back to the community they come from and make them responsible citizens. The basic point is that all detention is teaching kids the ways they will be inconvenienced and this will in turn cause resentments rather than helping them learn anything.

Author Bio:

This article was written by Ellie Harry, an educationist, and school teacher. She gives her best in essay writing help. She lives in Australia. She has the expert in academic writing.


Share This Story